Douglas went down 18-10 on their trip to Orrell Anvils.
The Manx side trailed 10-7 at half-time after skipper Bryn Snellgrove picked up a try and a conversion to pull them back into the game after they had conceded 10 early points.
A Snellgrove drop goal early in the second half levelled the scores but Orrell stole the game with a try and a penalty in the closing stages.
Tennis: Billy Harris defeated in French Open qualifiers
Former Island player suffers three-set loss at Roland Garros
Football: Braddan and Corinthians into Cowell Cup final
Elsewhere, Division 2 promotion race could be decided tonight (19 May)
Cycling: CC IoM names strong lineup for Ras Tailteann defence
Island team will head to Ireland this week as defending champions
Peter Hickman feeling confident ahead of TT 2026 campaign
Fourteen-time winner missed out on racing last year after crash