Forming a committee to assess the feasibility of nationalising the Steam Packet would have no benefit at this stage.
That's according to Infrastructure Minister Phil Gawne, who was among the 25 MHKs who voted against the move on Wednesday.
A Tynwald select committee was suggested amid concerns the Steam Packet may axe jobs and reduce passenger services as it competes with a rival freight service started by Mezeron.
Mr Gawne says the options for putting the Steam Packet Company into public ownership are unfeasible and he's holding ongoing talks with officials from both firms:
Yellow weather warning for gale force winds
Island offers consumer fuel protection advice
Ballabeg man declares intention to stand in 2026 General Election
Government 'might not be targeting the right people' to move to the Island says MHK