Calls for change in Manx political system amid governance concerns

Veteran journalist and political commentator discusses new ideas for the Island

Tynwald is set to debate the future of health and social care in the Isle of Man later this month but concerns are growing over a lack of public mandate on major policy decisions.

Political commentator Alistair Ramsay has highlighted what he describes as a 'democratic disconnect' arguing that government is making decisions on key issues - such as health funding, taxation, climate policy, and population growth - without clear direction from the electorate.

He suggests that Manx elections focus more on local personalities than national policies, leaving politicians to determine priorities without public input.

Mr Ramsay argues that a major shift in political culture is needed to fix this advocating for the public election of the chief minister:

He believes this would introduce 'proper national politics' enabling an all-Island debate on key policy choices and giving voters a direct say in the government's direction.

However the former government press officer acknowledges that sitting MHKs may resist such a change as it would reduce their influence in selecting the chief minister.

Opponents have previously argued that a ‘presidential’ system would be at odds with the Island’s traditions though Mr Ramsay counters that, historically, executive power was held by a crown-appointed governor.

With the possibility of electronic voting in the future Mr Ramsay believes public appetite for reform will grow and that candidates in the next general election may be forced to take notice.

Alistair Ramsay's article 'Government has no public mandate on health (or anything else)' can be read in full HERE.