Vagabonds had high hopes for a big result away at Oldershaw but the home side snatched the game 13-10.
Vagas led 5-3 at half-time courtesy of a Ross Pullman try.
In the second half, Leigh Kennaugh doubled Vagas’ tally but the strong Oldershaw side was too powerful for Vagas in the end.
Cricket: Lucy Barnett named August ICC Women's Player of the Month
Island player scoops award after standout international performances
Shooting: Kirkpatrick takes the win by one
Competitor also claims high gun in fifth summer sporting league round
Powerlifting: Isle of Man to begin Commonwealth championships campaign
Twelve local athletes taking on international event in Canada
Football: Island club wants community to design new crest and kit
Gymnasium AFC & Douglas Athletic FC merged during the summer