Vagabonds had high hopes for a big result away at Oldershaw but the home side snatched the game 13-10.
Vagas led 5-3 at half-time courtesy of a Ross Pullman try.
In the second half, Leigh Kennaugh doubled Vagas’ tally but the strong Oldershaw side was too powerful for Vagas in the end.
Boxing: Tyson Fury's sons part of Manx squad to face Merseyside & Cheshire
Local youth competitors to take to the ring in Douglas next month
Cycling: Rider views sought on latest MTB series
Three-round campaign concluded earlier this month
Football: Manx quartet feature in Tranmere Rovers victory
Island players help side to big FA Youth Cup win
Tennis: IoM team confirmed for 2027 Island Games
Eight players selected to compete in the Faroe Islands