Cav's lost the Gold Jersey at the Tour of Britain after a wind hit end to the third stage.
Lars Boom and Michael Matthews took first and second for Rabobank in Stoke-on-Trent.
A late attack by Sky's Alex Dowsett was chased down by the leading pack in the face of strong winds.
The uphill sprint to the finish turned into a bit of a melee with Dutchman Boom taking the line honours, Matthews second, Geraint Thomas third and Stephen Cummings fourth. Cavendish was fifth.
Boom's win edges Cavendish out at the top of the sprint leaderboard but he still starts Wednesday's Welshpool to Caerphilly stage in the points jersey.
New Year's fell race to take place in St John's
Rugby: Hopes for more Manx sides in local competitions in future
Football: More 'joined-up' approach sought between FA and Manx clubs
Tennis: Billy Harris called up to GB United Cup squad