Blame the Isle of Man's changing landscape, not sparrowhawks, for declining songbird numbers, says an MHK.
Bill Henderson was talking after farmer Ned Kennaugh told Manx Radio he thought there were more of the bird of prey on the Island.
He said sparrowhawks nesting on his land had scared off many other species of bird.
But Mr Henderson says there are other, more significant factors.
Castletown Commissioners to decrease rates for next financial year
Vice Chair John Cringle says it will provide 'much needed' support to residents
Man who died in Hillberry crash is named
Police renew dashcam footage appeal after single vehicle crash
DHSC responds to report into relationship with Manx Care
Plans to 'strengthen the partnership' as preferred option for future
Ranson case reforms under scrutiny in Tynwald debate
Backbenchers have challenged ministers over reforms introduced after the Ranson case