A petition to Tynwald Hill on the national day claims laws to protect young people risks 'sucking in many people to social care.'
It was handed over by Tristram Llewllyn Jones, a civil liberties campaigner.
He says the approach is not distinguishing carefully enough between those who need social care help and those who don't.
Plans for volunteer group to help with maintenance issues on the Island
Prisoners are already carrying out similar work
Increased demand for eye treatment
Minister warns it could impact waiting times
Armed Forces charity in Port Erin faces closure
The Port Erin Branch of the Royal British Legion has been active for close to 100 years
Ramsey MHK says government needs to step in and solve NCAS problem
Hooper believes centralising quarry income is the solution