Now Playing

Michael Jackson

Human Nature

Committee to look at impact of removing bishop's vote

No deadline set for producing a subsequent report

A new parliamentary committee has been tasked with further investigating whether the bishop should lose his vote.

Yesterday (25 June) in the Legislative Council MLC Bill Henderson called for the Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 to be referred to a committee.

He said he hoped this would provide a "chance to look at the topic in more depth" and better understand the potential impact on the Upper House.

Fellow MLC Kerry Sharpe suggested that removing the bishop's vote could be part of the "natural evolution of Tynwald" and expressed reluctance to support the committee's establishment.

No deadline has been set for the committee of three to report back - only that any report be completed 'as soon as practicable'.

It was a point queried by MLC Diane Kelsey.

Mr Henderson explained that this terminology was 'deliberate' to ensure the report's conclusions were not rushed.

MLC Dawn Kinnish agreed with Mr Henderson's approach stating: "We should take our time to achieve the right outcome".

Mr Henderson, who is against the removal of the bishop's vote, was asked if this could be seen as a stalling tactic:

Ramsey MHK Lawrie Hooper believes it is a stalling tactic:

The Vote

MLCs in favour of the committee:

  • Tanya August-Hanson
  • Paul Craine (seconder)
  • Peter Greenhill
  • Bill Henderson (mover)
  • Dawn Kinnish
  • Rob Mercer

MLCs against setting up the committee:

  • Kerry Sharpe
  • Diane Kelsey

The committee was approved and three MLCs were selected to sit on it - Bill Henderson, Paul Craine and Rob Mercer.

More from Isle of Man News